A clue, not a verdict

What is your loaf
trying to tell you?

Choose what you can observe, then follow the checks for that symptom. Keep the recipe and dough history beside the finished loaf.

A three-panel photograph of a bread slice and close-up views of its fine, airy crumb.
Contributed photograph of a slice and crumb details. Use photos alongside the baking record; this is not a chart of diagnosed faults. Image details · Photographer and original source not provided.

Find your next check.

Starter

Starter not rising after feeding

First question: Is this a new culture, or did it previously rise reliably?

Write down
Starter age, temperature, feeding weights, flour, bubbles and any high tide mark.
Common shortcut to avoid
Treating a quiet early day or a missed peak as proof the starter is dead.

Use the starter-specific checks before changing your dough recipe.

Investigate this symptom ↗
Dough & shape

Little or no rise

First question: Was the starter reliably rising after feeds, and what was the dough temperature?

Write down
Feeding history, mixing time, temperature and the marked starting level.
Common shortcut to avoid
Adding time without checking whether the starter was ready.

Separate a weak starter from cool dough or a difficult-to-see rise.

Investigate this symptom ↗
Crumb & texture

A dense or uneven crumb

First question: Is the whole crumb tight, or are there large tunnels surrounded by dense patches?

Write down
A fully cooled cross-section, bulk observations and shaping notes.
Common shortcut to avoid
Treating every dense loaf as a request for more water.

Compare fermentation, handling and the intended bread style.

Investigate this symptom ↗
Crumb & texture

Sticky, gummy crumb

First question: How long did the loaf cool, and what happened during the bake?

Write down
Loaf size, flour blend, oven settings, covered/uncovered times and slicing time.
Common shortcut to avoid
Diagnosing proofing from a warm slice alone.

Distinguish a cooling issue from baking, fermentation or formula effects.

Investigate this symptom ↗
Dough & shape

A loaf that spreads flat

First question: When did it spread: on the bench, out of the basket, or in the oven?

Write down
The moment of spreading, handling feel, flour, hydration and final-proof history.
Common shortcut to avoid
Blaming one factor without knowing when structure was lost.

Compare strength, shaping and proofing against the dough’s earlier behavior.

Investigate this symptom ↗
Crust & scoring

A crust that is too hard

First question: Is it thin and crisp or thick and difficult to bite, and how was the loaf stored?

Write down
Baking and cooling conditions, loaf size, vessel and storage method.
Common shortcut to avoid
Changing fermentation to solve a baking or storage symptom.

Separate crust thickness, moisture loss and what happened after baking.

Investigate this symptom ↗
Flavor

More or less tang than you wanted

First question: What changed in the flour, levain maturity or fermentation history?

Write down
The formula and process alongside the flavor of a cooled slice.
Common shortcut to avoid
Treating a longer cold proof or a stiff starter as a guaranteed sourness switch.

Choose one recipe variation and compare flavor alongside rise and texture.

Investigate this symptom ↗
Crust & scoring

A score that drags or will not open

First question: Did the cut drag, open broadly before loading, or stay closed in the oven?

Write down
Dough condition, blade and cut path, before-loading photo and baking setup.
Common shortcut to avoid
Assuming every score needs a deeper cut.

Separate the cut itself from dough strength, proofing and steam.

Investigate this symptom ↗
Starter

Gray liquid or an acetone smell

First question: Is the surface liquid, or is something fuzzy growing on it?

Write down
Color of the liquid, smell, how long since the last feed, and a photo of the jar.
Common shortcut to avoid
Throwing out a hungry starter, or stirring mold back into a feed.

Treat hooch as hunger. Treat fuzz, pink or orange as contamination.

Investigate this symptom ↗
Starter

Mold on the starter

First question: Do you see fuzz, or pink or orange streaks?

Write down
Where the growth sits, the color, and whether any other jar shared the utensil.
Common shortcut to avoid
Scraping the top and baking with the rest.

Throw the culture out, wash the jar, and restart from a healthy one.

Investigate this symptom ↗
Crumb & texture

Tight crumb and a bursting crust

First question: Had the dough risen much before it went into the oven?

Write down
Bulk notes, dough temperature, and a cooled cross-section.
Common shortcut to avoid
Adding water before you know the dough was simply early.

Give the next bulk more time or warmth, and keep the formula still.

Investigate this symptom ↗
Dough & shape

A loaf that rose and then spread

First question: Did the dough peak and then go slack?

Write down
When it looked strongest, dough temperature, and how it handled at shaping.
Common shortcut to avoid
Kneading in a pile of flour to rescue an exhausted dough.

Bake this one supported. Shape the next one earlier or keep it colder.

Investigate this symptom ↗
Crumb & texture

One large hole or a tunnel

First question: Is there one cavern, or an even pattern of open holes?

Write down
A full center slice, the shaping notes, and whether the crust also blew out.
Common shortcut to avoid
Kneading the next dough flat to punish every hole.

Match the hole to the loaf you wanted, then change shaping or proof, not both.

Investigate this symptom ↗
Crust & scoring

A blowout or a wild ear

First question: Where did the loaf split: the score, the side, or the seam?

Write down
A photo of the top and the bottom, plus whether the crumb is tight.
Common shortcut to avoid
Changing the blade, the proof and the steam on the same bake.

Name the split, then change the seam or the proof first.

Investigate this symptom ↗
Flavor

Bread going moldy in the bag

First question: Was the loaf cool before it was wrapped, and how long did it sit out?

Write down
Wrap, date baked, and whether the loaf was warm or stored near other mold.
Common shortcut to avoid
Cutting off the fuzzy corner and toasting the rest.

Cool, freeze the extra, and throw away a loaf that is already moldy.

Investigate this symptom ↗

Make one useful comparison.

  1. Describe the symptom and when it first appeared.
  2. Check the starter, formula, temperatures, fermentation and baking record.
  3. Choose one plausible change, then compare the next loaf.

This is a guide to baking quality. If a starter shows mold, pink or orange discoloration, discard it rather than trying to bake it safe. See Colorado State University Extension’s starter guidance and King Arthur Baking’s contamination FAQ.

Share this page

The page link does not include your calculator values or notes.