The short answer

Large holes are not one fault. An open country crumb is a pattern of irregular holes through the slice. A tunnel is a single cavern, often under the crust, with tighter crumb around it. Shaping can trap that pocket. Underproofing can too. Match the hole to the loaf you were baking.

  • Look at the whole slice, not the biggest hole.
  • A tunnel under the crust often comes from a shaping pocket or an early bake.
  • A sandwich loaf and a country loaf are allowed different holes.
Explore fix your loaf

Name the hole before you name the cause

Search results for large holes in sourdough mix two wishes. Some bakers want those holes and do not have them. Some bakers sliced a sandwich loaf and found a cave. This guide is for the second problem, and for the first only long enough to say that an even, open crumb is a different goal from deleting every hole. Look at a full cross-section after the loaf has cooled. One hole the size of a walnut with tight crumb everywhere else is a tunnel. Holes of many sizes spread through the slice are an open crumb.

The dense-crumb guide covers a slice that is tight all the way across. The gummy-crumb guide covers a slice that shines and clumps. Use those if the hole is not the main fact. Here, the hole is the main fact.

A tunnel under the crust

The usual tunnel sits just under the top crust. The roof of the hole is a thin baked shell. Under it, the crumb is finer and sometimes dense. Two causes show up again and again. The dough was underproofed, so the gas it did have collected at the top as the crust set. Or a large bubble was folded into the loaf at shaping and never pressed out. Both can be true. The underproofed loaf often also has a flying ear or a blowout. A well-proofed loaf with one sealed bubble looks more even everywhere except that pocket.

Do not knead the next dough into a brick to prevent a tunnel. For a country loaf, gently press only obvious oversized bubbles when you preshape. For a sandwich loaf, a slightly firmer degas is appropriate because you want an even slice. The sandwich guide explains that difference. Popping every blister on a hearth loaf is how you bake the tight crumb you were not asking about.

Huge irregular holes and a collapsing loaf

If the holes are large, the walls look thin and torn, and the loaf spread or domed and then fell, think of an overproofed or very slack dough rather than a single trapped bubble. The structure could not hold the gas it made. More folds during bulk, or an earlier shape, belong in the next experiment. Adding flour until the dough feels like modeling clay will remove the holes and also remove the loaf you were learning.

Very high hydration makes large holes more likely and handling less forgiving. If you jumped from 70% to 85% because a photo looked open, go back one step. The hydration guide is the place to change water. This page will not give you a percentage that guarantees an even open crumb in every kitchen.

Shaping is where pockets hide

When you letter-fold or roll a bâtard, flour on the inside of the dough can keep two surfaces from sealing. That dry pocket bakes into a slit that looks like a hole. Wet dough sealed without tension can trap a bubble in the center. Watch the seam. It should stick to itself. Loose flour belongs on the bench, not in the middle of the loaf.

A preshape and a short rest make the final shape calmer, so you are less likely to wrap a giant bubble into the loaf while you rush. The shaping guide shows the sequence. If your tunnels vanished the one time you shaped slowly and sealed the seam, you do not need a new starter. You need that shaping note in the bake log.

Flour, inclusions and the holes you should expect

Whole-wheat and rye doughs often have smaller holes than a white country loaf at the same hydration. If you added a large share of whole grain and then judged the loaf against a white open crumb, you may not have a fault at all. The grain guide explains the trade. Seeds, nuts and fruit create their own cavities. A hole around a walnut is not a fermentation tunnel. Note the inclusion before you diagnose the dough.

A lean 70% country formula, baked well, is allowed to be irregular. Sandwich bread is allowed to be close. Write the goal at the top of the page before you decide the holes are wrong. The bread-styles page is there so a boule and a pan loaf do not get the same crumb lecture.

How to read the next slice

Cool the loaf completely. Cut it through the center, not only at the heel. Lay the slice flat and look for three things: is there one dominant hole or many; is the crumb around it tight or open; did the crust blow out? One dominant hole plus a tight surround plus a blowout points at underproofing or a sealed bubble. Many thin-walled holes plus a flat loaf point at a slack, late dough. An even open crumb means you can stop troubleshooting holes.

Take the photo in daylight from straight above. A tilted close-up of the biggest hole makes every loaf look faulty. Put the formula weights in the same note. If starter percentage was wrong, the dough was not the one you think you are judging.

SliceRead it asNext single change
One tunnel under the crust, tight everywhere elseTrapped bubble or underproofSeal the shape, or lengthen bulk, not both at once
Many large weak holes, loaf spreadSlack or overproofed doughEarlier shaping or more strength from folds
Even irregular holes in a country loafOpen crumbKeep the formula and repeat it
Tight sandwich slice with one center gapShaping pocket in a pan loafDegas and seal the log that goes into the tin

Change one cause and bake again

If you choose underproofing as the cause, keep shaping the same and give bulk a longer window at the same temperature. If you choose shaping, keep the timing and only change how you seal the dough. If you choose hydration, move it by a small amount you can weigh, such as 2 percentage points of total water, and leave proof and shaping alone. The dense and underproofed guides agree on this discipline because holes are where bakers usually change everything.

Eat the loaf. A tunnel still makes toast. The experiment is the next cross-section, not a repair of the bread you have already baked.

FAQ

Why does my sourdough have one big hole under the crust?

That tunnel usually comes from a large bubble sealed in at shaping or from a loaf that was underproofed, so gas collected under the crust. Check the crumb around the hole and whether the crust also burst.

Are large holes a sign of good sourdough?

An open, irregular crumb can be what you want in a country loaf. A single cavern in a sandwich slice is a fault. Judge the hole against the style you mixed.

How do I stop huge holes without making the bread dense?

Press only the oversized bubbles when you shape a country loaf, and seal the seam so flour does not create a pocket. Do not knead the dough flat. If the whole crumb is tight, look at proof and flour choice instead.

Can underproofing cause large holes?

Yes. Underproofed loaves often show a few tunnels near the crust and a tighter crumb everywhere else, sometimes with a wild ear. A fully open crumb is a different pattern.

Does more water create bigger holes?

Higher hydration can make a more open, harder-to-handle crumb. It does not by itself explain one sealed tunnel. Change water only when the whole slice, not one pocket, is what you want to change.

Sources & further reading

This guide combines published references with our own explanations and decision aids. Numerical examples are illustrative; they are not records of Sourdough Bench test bakes.

Put it into practice.

Keep the recipe, observations and next change together in your downloadable bake log. For a symptom-led starting point, use the loaf troubleshooting guide.

Keep reading