The short answer

A blowout is a split where you did not intend one: along the seam, under the loaf, or beside a score that never opened. An ear is the raised lip along a deliberate score. The two can show up together when the loaf was tight inside and the crust found a weak point.

  • Name the split before you change the blade, the proof and the steam together.
  • A tall ear on a dense crumb is not, by itself, a successful score.
  • Seam placement, proof and the cut are three different checks.
Explore fix your loaf

Point to the split

Sourdough blowout searches usually come with a photo of a loaf that tore in an ugly place, or a score that stayed shut while the side exploded. Start by naming the opening. A seam blowout runs along the bottom or side where you sealed the dough. A score blowout is the cut itself ripping wider and deeper than you wanted. A side blowout ignores the score completely. An ear is the flap that lifts beside a slash when the loaf springs. You can have a tidy ear, no ear, or an ear next to a second uncontrolled split.

Those are different faults. A deeper cut will not repair a seam that was trapped under the loaf. More steam will not close a dough that was so underproofed it had to burst somewhere. Write one sentence: where it opened, and whether the score opened at all.

An ear is a result, not a grade

A modest ear on a country loaf means the score was the weak point and the loaf expanded there during oven spring. Bakers like the look. The crumb underneath still has to match the bread you wanted. A dramatic ear with a tight, damp interior often means the loaf was underproofed: the skin set, the score flew open, and the inside never had enough gas to fill out. Chasing a taller ear with a sharper angle will not fix that crumb.

No ear at all can mean the score was too shallow, the blade dragged, the surface was dry and tough, or the loaf was overproofed and spread instead of springing. It can also mean you baked seam-up and the seam opened instead of the cut. Look at the bottom of the loaf before you buy a new lame.

Seams blow out when they are the weakest line

If you shaped a boule and placed it seam-down in a pot, or seam-up in a basket and then turned it out, the seal has to survive the rise. A loose seam, flour trapped in the seal, or a seam that sat against a hot surface can open in the oven. The score on top then does little because the dough already found an exit. Next time, seal the seam on a lightly floured spot you can see, and place that seam where your method expects it. The shaping guide shows boule and bâtard seams without asking you to change hydration.

A blowout along the bottom of a Dutch oven loaf is often this seam, sometimes worsened by a dough that was still tight. It can also happen if the loaf sat in a pool of extra flour that kept the bottom from gripping. Brush off loose flour. Do not glue the seam with water you did not account for in the formula.

Proof changes where the loaf is allowed to open

An underproofed loaf has a strong skin and a tight interior. Oven spring is violent. The opening, wherever it is, looks explosive. Give the next loaf more bulk or a longer final proof before you change the blade. An overproofed loaf has little spring. The score may gap open and then sag, or the whole loaf may split weakly as it spreads. Shorten the proof before you cut deeper.

Cold loaves from an overnight proof score more cleanly when the surface is firm, and they can also hide underproofing because cold dough feels tight. Let the crumb from the last bake tell you whether the night was long enough. The overnight schedule page is the place to change that plan. The cut is the place to change only after the proof is in a range you recognize.

PatternOften travels withChange first
Tall ear, tight crumbUnderproofingMore time or warmth before the bake
Split along the bottom seamA weak seal or a seam on the hot surfaceSeam placement and shaping
Score stays shut, side explodesCut too shallow, or a drier weak spot elsewhereCut depth and surface, after proof is plausible
Score gapes, loaf spreads flatOverproofing or a slack doughEarlier shaping or a colder proof

The cut itself still has a job

Use a sharp blade and a decisive slash. A dragging cut snags the skin and makes a ragged ear even when proof was fine. Depth and angle belong to the scoring guide: a square cut opens differently from a shallow angled cut. Copy one pattern for a few bakes so you can see it. Changing angle, depth and the number of slashes on a loaf that also changed proof leaves you with a photograph and no cause.

Dusting the loaf with flour makes the ear easier to see and can also dry the skin. A skin that dried out during an uncovered proof will crack where it wants to, not where you cut. Cover the basket. If you like flour for the look, brush the excess off the score line so the blade meets dough.

Steam and heat open a loaf that is ready

Steam, or the lid of a Dutch oven, keeps the crust flexible for the first minutes so the score can open. Bake in a pot that was actually preheated if the recipe says to preheat it. A cold pot sets the split late and oddly. Taking the lid off too early can set a small ear before the loaf has sprung. Follow one covered and uncovered timing and write the minutes down.

Steam will not choose the seam over the score. If the loaf blew out at the base and the top score never moved, you still have a placement or proof problem. Use the steam guide when the whole crust is dull and thick and the opening was otherwise in the right place.

One next bake, one place to look

Pick the row in the table that matches the loaf. If you are unsure between proof and seam, repeat the same score and move only the seam, or repeat the same shaping and add a clearly longer bulk. Photograph the bottom of the loaf as well as the ear. Most blowout arguments are about a side of the bread nobody saved a picture of.

Sandwich loaves are a separate case. They often should not have a country-style ear at all. A split shoulder on a pan loaf is usually underproof or a tight log with an air pocket, which the sandwich and large-holes guides cover. Do not score a soft sandwich loaf like a boule unless the recipe tells you to.

FAQ

Why did my sourdough split at the side?

The crust opened at a weaker point than the score. Common causes are an underproofed dough, a shallow cut, or a seam placed where the loaf could burst. Name which of those matches the crumb before you change all three.

Why is there no ear on my sourdough?

The score may have been too shallow or the surface too dry, the seam may have opened instead, or the loaf may have been overproofed and spread. Check the bottom of the loaf and the crumb, not only the top crust.

Does a bigger ear mean better bread?

No. A tall ear with a tight crumb often means the loaf was underproofed. Judge the cooled slice together with the way the score opened.

Should I score deeper next time?

Deeper scoring helps when the old cut barely broke the skin and the loaf was otherwise well proofed. It does not fix a seam blowout or a dough that had not risen.

Can steam stop a blowout?

Steam helps a ready loaf open at the score. It will not move a split that is already happening along a weak seam or out of a tight, underproofed crumb.

Sources & further reading

This guide combines published references with our own explanations and decision aids. Numerical examples are illustrative; they are not records of Sourdough Bench test bakes.

Put it into practice.

Keep the recipe, observations and next change together in your downloadable bake log. For a symptom-led starting point, use the loaf troubleshooting guide.

Keep reading