What should I change next time?
Work backwards from a symptom, check the evidence, and choose a useful next experiment.
What you can work on.
- Separating similar-looking symptoms
- Checking the dough’s history before blaming hydration
- Choosing one change you can compare
A useful order.
Start with the first guide if this topic is new. If you already have a specific question, choose the guide that matches it and follow its worked examples or observation table.
See the full starter-to-loaf route
Sourdough Not Rising: Find Where Progress Stopped
Diagnose a slow starter, stalled bulk fermentation, lost volume after shaping, or low oven spring with a clear order of checks.

Underproofed Sourdough: Tight Crumb, Flying Crust and a Loaf That Was Not Ready
Recognize an underproofed sourdough loaf from the crumb, the crust and the dough you shaped. Separate it from a dead starter or a low-hydration formula.

Overproofed Sourdough: Spread, Collapse and a Weak Crumb
Spot an overproofed sourdough loaf that spread, wrinkled or baked into a fragile crumb. Decide whether to bake the dough you have, then change one timing next.

Dense Sourdough Crumb: Diagnose the Pattern Before Changing the Recipe
Separate a pleasantly close crumb from heavy or uneven sourdough, then review fermentation, flour, shaping, and hydration in order.

Gummy Sourdough Crumb: Check Cooling, Baking, and Fermentation
Trace a sticky sourdough center through cooling, loaf size, baking evidence, fermentation, and ingredient changes without guessing.

Large Holes in Sourdough: Open Crumb, Tunnels and Trapped Air
Tell an open sourdough crumb from a tunnel or a few huge holes. Separate underproofing, shaping pockets and a formula that was meant to be irregular.

Sourdough Spreading Flat: Find the Point Where Support Was Lost
Troubleshoot sourdough that spreads during mixing, shaping, basket release, or loading, with practical comparisons and hydration math.

Sourdough Blowout and Ear: Where the Crust Split and Why
Read a sourdough blowout at the seam, the score or the side, and separate a wild ear from a loaf that was underproofed or weakly shaped.

Sourdough Crust Too Hard: Separate Baking Problems from Storage
Diagnose thick, tough, or overly hard sourdough crust by timing and location, then adjust baking, steam, shape, or storage deliberately.
Share this page
The page link does not include your calculator values or notes.