The gas comes from yeast, and the dough has to hold it

The gas that inflates bread dough is carbon dioxide. In a sourdough loaf it comes from yeast living in the ripe levain, feeding on sugars from the flour. Gluten and the rest of the dough’s structure hold that gas as bubbles. Salt, malt, oil, and sugar do not make the gas. They change flavor, strength, and browning. Water changes how the dough feels and how much flour it can carry. The ingredient that leavens the bread on this site is the ripe starter.

Commercial yeast produces the same gas from a packaged culture. It is a real way to raise dough, and it is not the path these formulas use. Baking powder and baking soda raise a batter by a chemical reaction between an acid and an alkali. That is a different product, used for quick breads and cakes, not a levain you feed. Do not swap a teaspoon of baking powder for the starter in a country loaf, a bagel, or a focaccia and expect the same dough.

PathWhat makes the gasWhat this site does with it
Ripe levainYeast in the starter, fed by flourThe main path. Feed it, then mix it when it has risen.
Commercial yeastThe same gas, from a packageNot these formulas. Some publishers add it beside starter.
Baking powder or baking sodaA chemical reaction, not a fermentationNot a substitute for the doughs on this site.

The starter path runs through tools you already have

A levain is ready to mix when a recent feed has risen and the jar smells tangy, not rotten or moldy. The starter-feeding calculator plans the grams of seed, flour, and water. It does not tell you the jar has peaked. The dough calculator then splits a loaf into flour, water, salt, and that starter, including the flour and water already inside the starter. Hydration is that water divided by that flour. It is not a measure of how fast the dough will rise.

Temperature changes the clock, not the ingredient. Desired dough temperature is the reading you want in the dough just after mixing, and the dough temperature calculator estimates the water that gets you there. There is no second calculator on this page. If the mixed dough is warmer or cooler than the recipe assumed, the proofing time changes. The leavening is still the starter.

A dense loaf or a collapse is not a reason to change leaveners

A dense crumb usually means the dough did not ferment enough, the starter was sluggish, or the piece was too tight for the gas it did make. A loaf that rose and then fell is often overproofed: the structure let go of gas it had already made. Those are different faults. Adding a packet of commercial yeast, or a spoon of baking powder, on top of a formula written for starter only, does not identify which one you had. It gives you a dough this site did not write.

Read the not-rising guide and the dense-crumb guide before you change ingredients. Read the overproofed guide if the dough had already ballooned and then slumped. Bagels and focaccia in this library are starter-only ledgers with their own schedules. King Arthur’s published focaccia also lists instant yeast. That yeast is theirs. Do not paste it into our focaccia grams and keep our clock.

The leavening choice

Choose a ripe levain for the breads on this site. Feed it on a schedule you can repeat, then mix it when it has risen. Commercial yeast is a different product and belongs on recipes written for it. Chemical leaveners are not this site’s main path for bread dough. They belong on batters written for them. If you mix those paths into one bowl because a package is open, the clock and the flavor both stop matching the page you opened.

Write down which leavening you used. A later loaf is comparable only if that choice stayed still. The bake log is the place for the dough temperature, the feed, and the result. The next change should be one thing, not a new leavener and a new hydration on the same day.

FAQ

Which ingredient makes bread dough rise?

Yeast. In these formulas that yeast is living in a ripe sourdough starter. Flour feeds it and the dough holds the carbon dioxide. Salt, malt, and fat do not leaven the loaf.

Can I use commercial yeast instead of starter?

Not in these ledgers. Commercial yeast makes the same gas and is a different product, with a different clock. Use a recipe written for it rather than stirring a packet into a starter-only formula.

Will baking powder replace my starter?

No. Baking powder and baking soda are chemical leaveners. They are not the main path for the breads on this site, and they do not turn a bagel or a focaccia formula into the same dough.

Where do I plan the water temperature?

In the dough temperature calculator. The desired-dough-temperature guide explains the target. This page does not add a second tool.

Sources & further reading

This guide combines published references with our own explanations and decision aids. Numerical examples are illustrative; they are not records of Sourdough Bench test bakes.

Put it into practice.

Keep the recipe, observations and next change together in your downloadable bake log. For a symptom-led starting point, use the loaf troubleshooting guide.

Keep reading