Sourdough Bagels: Overnight Rings, Boiled Then Baked
Sourdough bagels are a firm dough of bread flour, water, salt, ripe starter, and barley malt syrup, shaped into rings, boiled, then baked. This batch is eight bagels from 500 g of flour, shaped in the evening and cold-proofed overnight. Shaping and troubleshooting stay on the bagel guide.
View saved recipes · Saved on this device.

These bagels are a firm dough: bread flour, water, salt, ripe starter, and barley malt syrup. Total flour is 500 g at 58% hydration. The batch is eight rings, about 102 g each, shaped in the evening and baked the next morning after a cold proof. It is a planning formula, not a record of a Sourdough Bench test bake. Boil them, then bake them. Skipping the boil makes a different bread. Shaping faults and dense rings stay on the bagel guide.
King Arthur’s sourdough bagels are a larger dozen, with honey in the dough and a room-temperature overnight bulk before shaping. Their boil uses honey and salt, and they bake at 475°F. The Perfect Loaf’s new-wave bagels use a higher-hydration blend, a cold proof after shaping, and a malt-and-baking-soda boil. This card keeps the cold overnight proof and that style of boil, at these gram weights, with starter only. The dough calculator checks flour, water, salt, and starter. It does not count malt syrup as water.
Baker’s percentages for this bagel dough
| Ingredient | Baker’s % of total flour | Weight |
|---|---|---|
| Total flour | 100% | 500 g |
| Prefermented flour | 15% | 75 g |
| Starter at 100% hydration | 30% by weight | 150 g |
| Water to weigh | 43% | 215 g |
| Total water, including starter | 58% hydration | 290 g |
| Fine salt | 2% | 10 g |
| Barley malt syrup in the dough | 3% | 15 g |
| Bread flour to weigh | — | 425 g |
| Dough weight before the boil | — | 815 g |
Overnight schedule, then boil and bake
| When | Stage | What to look for |
|---|---|---|
| Evening | Mix and a short bulk | About 60–90 minutes, puffy but not doubled |
| Evening | Shape eight rings | About 102 g each, hole opened, seam sealed |
| Overnight | Cold proof | Covered in the refrigerator for 8–16 hours |
| Morning | Boil | 30 seconds per side in malt water with a little baking soda |
| Morning | Bake | 450°F / 230°C for 18–24 minutes, until deep gold and firm |
Sourdough Bagels: Overnight Rings, Boiled Then Baked
- Makes
- 8 bagels
- Prep · estimate
- 40 min
- Cook · estimate
- 24 min
- Total · estimate
- 64 min
Ingredients
- 425 g white bread flour, plus a little for the bench
- 215 g water, cool or at the temperature you calculated
- 150 g ripe sourdough starter at 100% hydration (75 g flour and 75 g water)
- 10 g fine salt
- 15 g barley malt syrup, for the dough
- 2 L water, for the boil
- 20 g barley malt syrup, for the boil
- 4 g baking soda, for the boil
- optional sesame seeds, poppy seeds, or everything seasoning, for the tops
Method
Confirm the starter and the ledger
Use a starter that has risen on a recent feed and smells tangy, not rotten or moldy. Total flour is 500 g. The 150 g starter contributes 75 g of that flour and 75 g water, so prefermented flour is 15%. You weigh 425 g more flour. Water to weigh is 215 g. Total water is 290 g, which is 58% hydration. Salt is 10 g, 2%. Barley malt syrup in the dough is 15 g, 3%. Dough weight before boiling is 815 g. The boil water, the malt in the pot, and the baking soda are not part of that dough weight and they are not hydration. If your starter is not 100% hydration, rebuild the flour and water split before you mix. Do not start from a boule formula and punch a hole in it.
Mix a firm dough
Stir the starter, the 215 g water, the 15 g malt syrup, and the salt into the flour until no dry flour remains. Knead until the dough is smooth, tight, and elastic. By machine that may take several minutes. By hand it takes longer. The dough should feel firm and bouncy, not like a wet country loaf. Flour the bench lightly if you need to, and do not work in so much extra flour that you leave the 425 g behind. Write down the dough temperature. The desired-dough-temperature guide and the dough temperature calculator are how you set the water. They do not change these grams.
Give it a short bulk
Cover the dough and let it sit until it is slightly puffy, often about 60 to 90 minutes in a room near 75°F / 24°C. You are not waiting for it to double. A bagel dough that over-ferments will slump in the boil. If the kitchen is cold, give it more time and judge the dough, not the clock. This evening rise is only the start. The overnight cold proof is the schedule.
Divide and shape eight rings
Turn the dough out and divide it into eight pieces of about 102 g. Shape each into a tight ball and rest them, covered, for about 10 minutes. Poke a hole through the center with a floured finger and stretch the ring until the hole is about 4 cm / 1½ inches. The hole will shrink. Set the rings on a lightly floured sheet, with space between them. If a join looks weak, press it. Rings that open in the pot are a shaping problem the bagel guide already covers. Do not rest them uncovered until a skin cracks.
Cold-proof overnight
Cover the sheet and refrigerate it for at least 8 hours and up to about 16. The chill firms the rings so they hold their shape in the water, and it is the preferred schedule on this card. A same-morning bake is the swap below, not the plan. Do not leave the shaped rings on a warm counter overnight.
Boil, then bake
Heat the oven to 450°F / 230°C. Bring the 2 L of water, the 20 g malt syrup, and the 4 g baking soda to a boil in a wide pot. The malt is the sugar in the pot. The baking soda is the alkali. They do different jobs: flavor and browning. Do not stir the baking soda into the dough. Boil the cold rings two or three at a time, 30 seconds on the first side and 30 seconds on the second. Lift them out, let the water drip off, and set them on a parchment-lined sheet. Dip the tops in seeds while they are still wet if you want a topping. Bake 18 to 24 minutes, until the crust is deep gold and the sides feel firm. Rotate the sheet once if your oven has a hot side. King Arthur bakes their bagels at 475°F and looks for about 210°F / 99°C in the center. That is their cue, not a reading from this kitchen. Write down any temperature you actually measure. Cool on a rack before you slice.
Developed for home use; not kitchen-tested by Sourdough Bench. Times are estimates; use the doneness cues in the steps.
Small things that help
- The formula and the boil are both required
- Bagel formula means this ledger: 500 g total flour, 58% hydration, 2% salt, 3% malt in the dough, 15% prefermented flour. Boil, then bake means the rings go through the pot before the oven. A baked ring that skipped the water is a different bread. The guide explains why. This card is the grams and the clock.
- The dough calculator ignores the malt and the pot
- Enter 500 g total flour, 58% hydration, 2% salt, 15% prefermented flour, and a starter at 100% hydration. You should get 425 g flour to weigh, 215 g water, 150 g starter, and 10 g salt. Add the 15 g malt yourself. Do not type the boil water in as dough water.
- Unfed discard is not this starter
- The 150 g line is ripe starter. If the jar is unfed discard, feed it and wait until it rises, or use the discard calculator for a bake that expects discard. Do not drop 150 g of discard into this ledger and keep the same overnight clock.
Make it your own
- Bake them the same day
- Skip the refrigerator. After shaping, cover the rings and let them puff slightly at room temperature, often 30 to 60 minutes, then boil and bake. That is a same-day plan. It is not the overnight schedule. Write down which one you used. Rings that overproof on the counter will wrinkle in the pot.
- Use honey instead of malt syrup
- Replace the 15 g malt in the dough and the 20 g malt in the boil with the same weights of honey. Change only that sweetener on the bake you are logging. Honey is not vegan. Barley malt syrup is the default on this card.
- Want a soft enriched dough instead
- Do not enrich these rings with egg and butter and still call them this bagel. Brioche is the loaf. Cinnamon rolls are the sweet pan. Both are separate formulas.
Make ahead & storage
Cool the bagels on a rack until the centers are no longer warm. Keep what you will eat in a day or two in a clean bag at room temperature. Freeze the rest once cool. Do not seal them while they are hot. If you see mold, throw the bagels away. Trimming one ring is not enough. The mold guide is the storage decision, including fridge versus freezer. The starter-mold guide is a different jar.
Dietary notes
Ingredients to check
The dough contains wheat flour and barley malt syrup. The boil contains more barley malt syrup and baking soda. There is no egg, milk, or butter. This is not brioche. A honey swap is not vegan. Seed toppings are optional and are not part of the dough ledger.
Before you start
Do I boil the bagels before they bake?
Yes. Boil about 30 seconds per side, then bake at 450°F / 230°C. The boil is part of this formula. The bagel guide explains what changes if you skip it.
Is the overnight cold proof required?
It is the schedule on this card. A same-day proof is a swap, and you should write down which clock you used. Do not leave shaped rings on a warm counter overnight.
Can I use my usual boule dough?
No. Start from these grams. A high-hydration country dough reshaped into a ring is a different bread. Troubleshooting stays on the bagel guide.
Sources & inspiration
- King Arthur Baking: Sourdough bagels
A published dozen with honey in the dough, a room-temperature overnight bulk, a honey-and-salt boil, and a 475°F bake. The eight-bagel ledger, cold proof after shaping, and malt-and-soda boil here are ours.
- The Perfect Loaf: New-wave sourdough bagels
A higher-hydration blend with a cold proof after shaping and a boil of barley malt syrup plus baking soda. Their flour blend and levain build are not these weights.
- King Arthur Baking: Baker’s percentage
The percentage language used to build the 500 g flour ledger.
Recipe writing and serving illustrations are created for Sourdough Bench. Inspiration credits identify the source of an idea; they do not imply that another author tested this recipe. How we publish.


