Lunch

Greek Yogurt Chicken Salad Sourdough Sandwich

A chicken salad sandwich with plain Greek yogurt, celery, dill and a little Dijon, tucked into lightly toasted sourdough with crisp lettuce.

Jump to recipe

View saved recipes · Saved on this device.

Two uneven sourdough sandwich halves filled with shredded chicken, a creamy yogurt dressing, chopped celery, dill and lettuce.
AI-generated serving illustration.

This Greek yogurt chicken salad starts with cooked, chilled chicken and a small bowl of thick yogurt dressing. Celery brings a clean crunch, dill adds a fresh edge, and half a teaspoon of Dijon is enough to sharpen the filling without covering the chicken.

Make one generous sandwich from two slices of sourdough. Lightly toast the cut faces, let the steam escape, then tuck lettuce beneath the filling. The result should be easy to bite through, with loose chicken shreds rather than a compressed, perfectly smooth paste. The preparation estimate assumes the chicken is already cooked and cold.

Let’s put it together

Greek Yogurt Chicken Salad Sourdough Sandwich

Makes
1 sandwich, cut into 2 halves
Prep · estimate
12 min
Cook · estimate
3 min
Total · estimate
15 min

Ingredients

  • 2 slices (100 g total) sourdough, about 1 cm / ⅜ inch thick
  • 100 g cooked, chilled boneless chicken, skin removed
  • 50 g plain thick Greek yogurt made with pasteurized milk
  • 20 g celery, finely chopped
  • 1 tsp finely chopped fresh dill
  • ½ tsp Dijon mustard
  • 2 small leaves (about 15 g) lettuce, washed and thoroughly dried

Method

  1. Prepare the cold ingredients

    Wash and dry the celery, dill and lettuce. Pull the cooked chicken into short, uneven shreds, cutting any long strands across once so they will not drag the filling out when you bite. Keep raw poultry and its utensils away from these ready-to-eat ingredients.

  2. Fold the filling

    Stir the yogurt and Dijon together in a small bowl. Add the celery, dill and chicken, then fold just until the shreds are coated. Stop before the mixture becomes a paste. If the yogurt has separated, pour away the visible whey before measuring it.

  3. Toast and cool

    Toast the bread lightly for about 2–3 minutes, leaving the center flexible. Stand the slices on their edges for a minute so steam can escape. Very hot toast will warm the salad and soften the lettuce.

  4. Build one sandwich

    Cover one slice with the dried lettuce. Spoon the filling over it in a loose layer, leaving a small margin at the edge. Close with the second slice and press only enough to hold it together. Cut once across the middle with a serrated knife; serve the two halves immediately.

Developed for home use; not kitchen-tested by Sourdough Bench. Times are estimates; use the doneness cues in the steps.

Small things that help

Fix a loose Greek yogurt chicken salad
Drain the yogurt before mixing and pat damp celery dry. If the finished salad is loose, fold in a little additional cooked chicken from your refrigerated supply, or serve it open-faced. Adding more bread will not correct a watery dressing.
Choose the bread for the job
A slice with a few larger holes is fine because the lettuce catches the filling. Very thick crust or deeply toasted bread can push the salad out, so use a light toast and a sharp serrated knife.

Make it your own

Use cooked turkey
Replace the chicken with the same weight of chilled cooked turkey. Its previous storage time still counts; making a new salad does not restart the clock.
Change the herb
Use 1 teaspoon finely sliced chives instead of dill. If you dislike mustard, omit it; the yogurt still provides a tangy dressing.

Make ahead & storage

Store filling separately from bread and lettuce at 4°C/40°F or below. Use within 3 days when made with freshly cooked chicken, or sooner if any ingredient is older. Refrigerate within 2 hours, or 1 hour above 32°C/90°F. Use ice packs when taking it for lunch.

Dietary notes

Ingredients to check

Contains wheat, milk and mustard. Plain Greek yogurt provides a tangy dressing; check the mustard and bread labels for any additional allergens.

Before you start

Can I start with raw chicken?

Yes, but allow extra cooking and chilling time. Cook chicken to 74°C/165°F at its thickest point, then refrigerate promptly in a shallow container. Use it cold in this salad; do not leave it on the counter to cool for hours.

Can I use ordinary plain yogurt?

Strain it until thick before measuring 50 g. Thin yogurt tends to soak into the bread; sweetened or flavored yogurt changes the savory dressing.

Watch the technique

These creator videos offer extra guidance. Their ingredients and quantities may differ from the recipe above.

Greek Yogurt Chicken Salad | Eating Bird Food #recipe #chickensalad #mealprep #greekyogurt

By Eating Bird Food

Related technique: Greek-yogurt chicken salad by Eating Bird Food. Our sandwich uses the amounts and additions listed above.

YouTube loads only when you choose “Load video”.

Watch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

Sources & inspiration

Recipe writing and serving illustrations are created for Sourdough Bench. Inspiration credits identify the source of an idea; they do not imply that another author tested this recipe. How we publish.

Share this page

The page link does not include your calculator values or notes.